Tests & Articles
Correct ways of testing & evaluating color change, color shift & fluorescent gemstones and minerals
Written by: Ales Patrick Krivanek, Ravenstein Gem Co.
Alexandrite was originally discovered in the Ural mountains of Russia in the early 1840s, approximately forty years before Edison’s discovery of the incandescent light type lightbulb. Before 1880, the only type of light used by households of both the rich and the poor after sundown was the flame of oil lanterns and candles.
At that time, Russian Alexandrite was a gem owned and worn strictly by the royal family. Alexandrite was described as having the color of Emerald during the day and the color of Amethyst at night. The original Russian description was slightly changed in the western world to “Emerald by day, and Ruby by night”, when the stone was observed under the orangey-yellow light of candles.
I recently had a discussion with Craig Lynch GG, of Ouellet & Lynch, regarding the use of correct, historically proven types of lighting that doesn’t leave room for mistakes when it comes to the testing, evaluating, imaging and displaying of Alexandrite and other color change gems & minerals. Lynch is an expert in his field, specializing in rare, high-value & unique gemstones, such as Blue Color Change Garnet, Russian Demantoid & Dragon Garnet (*).
Color change stones are typically displayed and/or photographed using 2 types of light:
The use of incandescent light is the core problem. In order to mimic the light temperature of the candle flame (not to be mistaken with the actual temperature of the flame itself) you need a light source producing light in 1900° to 2100° Kelvin.
In the vast majority of cases, most people (including professionals), have been using the wrong light source. In reality, there is a fairly substantial difference in the appearance of a color change gemstone when viewed under the proper light temperature (1900° - 2100° Kelvin) versus the wrong light temperature (2700° - 3000° Kelvin).
I hope that one of the many overseas manufacturers of these specialized flashlights for gemology will read this article and take proper steps to start correcting this industry wide problem. Any reasonable thinking professional will want to have a light source that is actually producing the correct light temperature, which is verifiable and supported by historic facts.
I have confidence that this information will help many of you take proper, correct images of color change & color-shift gemstones.
(*) = Dragon Garnet exhibits either a strong color change or color-shift properties, as well as medium to strong fluorescence. The gem’s color changes both in visible spectrum of light (daylight/ neutral white light at 5500° to 6500° Kelvin & candlelight at 1900° to 2100 degrees Kelvin) and under UV light (260nm UV, 365nm UV & 395nm UV wavelengths).
(*) = Dragon Garnet changes its color under all of the following light temperatures & wavelengths. ▼
Daylight
( 5000°K )
Candle light
( 2000°K )
Blue light
( 450 nm )
UV light
( 395 nm )
UV light
( 365 nm )
UV light
( 260 nm )
Dragon Garnet lab test by GIA
Daylight
( 5000°K )
Candle light
( 2000°K )
Blue light
( 450 nm )
UV light
( 395 nm )
UV light
( 365 nm )
UV light
( 260 nm )